Our Insurance Providers

Lake Michigan Insurance Agency provides access to value-driven insurance coverage through our partnership with quality carriers. We’ve chosen these companies because they offer the best of the best. When you use LMIA for your insurance needs, we search among them all for the best policies and lowest pricing.

Whether you’re looking for home, life, auto, commercial insurance coverage, let’s get together to discuss your needs.

And we’ll do the shopping for you.

Personal/Commercial Insurance

Auto-owners ›

Auto-Owners Insurance

Auto-Owners backs up its products by providing its famous “No Problem” claims service. The company is represented by over 42,000 licensed agents in 26 states and offers multiple lines of insurance including life, home, auto and business.

Citizens ›


Citizens Insurance Company of America, based in Howell, Michigan, is a leading provider of personal and commercial property and casualty insurance, primarily in the Midwest. Founded in 1915, Citizens is a member of The Hanover Insurance Group, based in Worcester, Mass.

Foremost ›

As a specialty insurance company, we serve our markets by providing insurance choices that may not be offered by other companies. So, if you’re wondering whether or not we can insure a particular product, check us out. Our extensive insurance options may surprise you!

Frankenmuth ›


Insurance should be boring. Forgettable. Drama-free. At Frankenmuth Insurance, we sweat the small stuff and make sure you have the protection that’s right for you. It all begins with a frank conversation, because we believe the best relationships are honest, upfront and fair. They build trust over time. It’s how we’ve done business for 150 years.

Grange ›


Our agents are independent, local and ready to help
At Grange, our independent agents get to know you personally and create customized insurance policies that fit your needs.

Hastings Mutual ›

Hastings Mutual

For well over 100 years, Hastings Mutual Insurance Company has built an outstanding reputation based on quality customer service and needed insurance products, backed by sound company finances. We are indeed proud of our past and look forward to a progressive future of serving you!

Michigan Insurance Company ›

Our commitment has been in partnering with our independent agencies to ultimately provide outstanding customer service with quality insurance products to our customers. We understand that insurance is more than policies and numbers. It’s the people that matter.

Pioneer State Mutual ›

Pioneer State Mutual

Pioneer State Mutual offers a wide array of insurance options including auto, homeowners, farm owners, mobile homeowners and commercial policies, all expertly tailored to your specific needs and concerns.

Progressive ›


Progressive Insurance lives up to its name by staying one step ahead of the Insurance Industry, while finding new and affordable solutions. Progressive Insurance began in 1937 with the 1st drive-in claims department. They were the 1st to introduce low rates for low-risk drivers. Progressive was also the 1st to offer competitive insurance rates on the web.

State Auto ›

State Auto

Throughout our nearly 100-year history, we’ve developed a well-respected heritage and built a strong foundation. We’ve always celebrated a culture of people who care. Who deliver exceptional service. Who plant themselves firmly in the communities they serve. Who genuinely understand their customers. And who develop trusted relationships.

Personal Insurance Carriers

Safeco ›


We know that trust matters when it comes to some of your biggest investments, like your home, car, and even your boat. From the smallest fender-bender to a storm-damaged home, we’re standing ready at life’s trying moments – here for you at any time, at any day of the week.

Wolverine ›


For over 100 years, Wolverine Mutual Insurance Company has proudly told our policyholders that “it’s covered” when they need that assurance the most. Through a conservative stewardship of our policyholders’ money, personal property insurance policies that are written to truly protect what they own and a company-wide compassion during tough times, we’ve built a family of customers, agents and employees that have spanned generations.

Commercial Insurance Carriers

Travelers ›

Travelers takes on the risk and provides the coverage you need to protect the things that are important to you – your home, your car, your valuables and your business – so you don’t have to worry. We have been around for more than 160 years and have earned a reputation as one of the best property casualty insurers in the industry because we take care of our customers. Our expertise and focus on innovation have made us a leader in personal, business and specialty insurance and the only property casualty company in the Dow Jones Industrial Average.

The Hartford ›

The Hartford

As a company in business for more than 200 years, we understand what it means to be sustainable. We have helped people and businesses prepare for the unexpected, protect what is uniquely important to them, and prevail through life’s challenges and opportunities.

Acuity ›


In business since 1925, we protect individuals, families, and businesses with innovative insurance products backed by world-class customer service.


EMC Insurance

With more than 100 years of strength, stability and success, we’ve proven our agents, policyholders, investors and team members can Count on EMC®

Life Insurance

Lake Michigan Insurance Agency is owned by Lake Michigan Credit Union.

The information contained herein is provided solely for general informational purposes and is not intended to be a contract, a solicitation or an offer to sell in connection with any product or service, nor is the information a complete description of all terms, conditions and exclusions applicable to the products and services described.

Email Us

* Required Fields