Scams and fraud are becoming more sophisticated, more frequent, and harder to recognize. From unexpected text messages and emails to convincing phone calls and elaborate impersonation schemes, fraudsters are constantly finding new ways to target your money and personal information.
So how can you tell when something isn't right?
On this episode of Wallet Wisdom, Brett sits down with Natalie, Market Leader at LMCU's Port Charlotte location, to talk about the fraud and scams she has encountered firsthand. With more than 11 years of experience in the credit union industry, Natalie has seen how quickly a seemingly legitimate situation can turn into a costly scam.
Her biggest piece of advice? Slow down, verify what's happening, and talk to someone you trust.
1. Be cautious when something feels unexpected
One of the biggest warning signs of a scam is an unexpected message, phone call, email, or investment opportunity. If someone suddenly contacts you about an investment, cryptocurrency, a financial opportunity, or an account problem that you weren't already expecting, don't assume it's legitimate.
Why it matters: Scammers often initiate contact and create a sense that you need to respond immediately. By catching you off guard, they hope you'll act before you have time to question what's happening.
How to protect yourself: If you weren't expecting the communication, take a step back. Don't click links, send money, provide personal information, or respond until you've independently verified who contacted you.
If you're unsure, contact the organization directly using a phone number or website you already know and trust.
2. Don't let urgency make the decision for you
Urgency is one of the most common tactics scammers use. They may tell you that your account is in danger, a loved one is in trouble, you'll be arrested, or you need to send money immediately. The goal is to create fear or anxiety so you don't stop to think.
As Natalie explains, if someone is pressuring you to act immediately, that's a major red flag.
Why it matters: When we're anxious or afraid, we're more likely to react instead of carefully evaluating what's happening. Scammers know this and use urgency to their advantage.
How to protect yourself: Remember: You don't have to make an immediate financial decision just because someone says you do.
Pause. Take a breath. Give yourself time to think. Then verify the situation through a trusted source before taking action.
3. Trust your gut when something doesn't add up
Sometimes the warning sign isn't one specific detail. It's simply the feeling that something isn't right.
Natalie shared a story about someone who attempted to use a fraudulent identity at her branch. The identification appeared legitimate at first, but when Natalie compared the information with what she knew about the member, something didn't add up. Instead of proceeding, she stopped and investigated. That decision ultimately helped law enforcement uncover a larger fraud ring.
Why it matters: Your instincts can be an important first line of defense. If something feels unusual, inconsistent, or too good to be true, it's worth taking a closer look.
How to protect yourself:
Pay attention when:
- The story doesn't quite make sense.
- You're being asked to send money somewhere unusual.
- Someone is pressuring you to keep a transaction secret.
- The information you're receiving conflicts with what you already know.
- An offer seems too good to be true.
- You simply have a feeling that something isn't right.
You don't have to prove that something is a scam before you stop and ask questions.
4. Talk to someone you trust
One of the most important steps you can take when you're unsure about a situation is to talk to another person. That could be a family member, friend, financial professional, law enforcement, or someone at your financial institution.
Why it matters: Scammers often try to isolate their victims. They may tell you not to talk to your bank or credit union, not to tell your family, or not to discuss the situation with anyone else. That's a major red flag.
Having another person look at the situation can give you perspective and help you recognize warning signs you may have missed.
How to protect yourself: Before sending money or providing sensitive information, talk to someone you trust.
At LMCU, members can also visit a branch or contact the credit union when they have questions about a suspicious situation. Having a real person to talk to can make a big difference.
5. Don't be embarrassed to ask for help
Fraud can happen to anyone. Natalie shared a particularly difficult story about a longtime member who repeatedly came into the branch to withdraw large amounts of money. Each time, he provided an explanation that seemed reasonable. Eventually, he revealed that he had been scammed and had lost more than $100,000.
What makes stories like this especially difficult is that scammers can be incredibly convincing.
Why it matters: Feeling embarrassed or ashamed can make people less likely to ask for help. Unfortunately, that can allow a scam to continue.
Scammers may even intentionally convince victims that their financial institution, family members, or friends cannot be trusted.
How to protect yourself: If you've already sent money, shared information, or realized you've fallen for a scam, don't hide it because you're embarrassed.
Tell someone you trust and report the situation as soon as possible. The sooner you ask for help, the sooner you can begin taking steps to protect yourself.
The Three-Step Fraud Check: Pause, Verify and Talk to Someone You Trust
When you're faced with a suspicious message, phone call, request for money, or unexpected financial opportunity, remember three simple steps:
- Pause. Don't let fear or urgency force you into making a quick decision.
- Verify. Contact the organization or person independently using information you know is legitimate.
- Talk to someone you trust. A second perspective can help you recognize a scam before it's too late.
These steps can give you the time and perspective you need to make a safer decision.
Your Money Matters. Protect It.
Fraudsters are constantly changing their tactics, but you don't have to face those tactics alone.
LMCU's branches, call center, and financial professionals are available to help members navigate questions and concerns about their finances. The credit union also works to provide financial education and fraud awareness resources in the communities it serves.
As Natalie put it, every dollar matters. Taking a few extra moments to pause, verify, and ask for help could make all the difference.